The Moonstone was published in 1868 and is considered by most people to be the first detective novel Given the novels place in the history of the genre, that alone should put this book on most people s reading lists To sweeten the pot, the plot is compelling, the last hundred pages I couldn t have put the book down for anything I was caught up in the case and wanted to find out the why and the who in the mysterious circumstances surrounding the MOONSTONE.The novel is narrated by several different people My favorite was Gabriel Betteredge, the head servant at the Verinder house, who becomes a reluctant Watson for Detective Cuff during the investigation He is a man convinced in the spiritual guidance of Robinson Crusoe and believes that any disruption in his life can be explained by reading and interpreting passages from his dogeared copy of Defoe s classicIn this anxious frame of mind, other men might have ended by working themselves up into a fever I ended in a different way I lit my pipe, and took a turn at Robinson CrusoeBetteredge is a man of his age and his views on women I found so ridiculous as to actually laugh out loudIt is a maxim of mine that men being superior creatures are bound to improve women if they can When a woman wants me to do anything I always insist on knowing why The oftener you make them rummage their own minds for a reason, the manageable you will find them in all the relations of life It isn t their fault poor wretches that they act first, and think afterwards it s the fault of the fools who humour them Despite his archaic views, Betteredge proves to be a good assistant to the enigmatic Sergeant Cuff Cuff s eyes had such intensity,looking as if they expected something from you than you were aware of yourselfWilkie Collins based his character Sergeant Cuff on a real celebrated Victorian Detective Inspector Jack Whicher Sergeant Cuff is summoned from London to investigate the disappearance of the Moonstone, and despite the reluctance of the household to help him in his investigations, he does come up with a theory kept from us that proves in the final pages of the book that he is worthy of his reputation Cuff is as equally interested in the rose gardens he has strong opinions as he is in the crime he is investigatinggrass walkways never gravelCollins does a great job putting flesh on the bones of the characters We learn about every major character than is necessary for the advancement of the plot By the end of the novel I had the feeling that I was not only closing the cover on a great book, but also leaving behind some dear friends Another narrator, that I was not fond of, in fact, she made my skin crawl is Drusilla Clack A cousin of the family, Drusilla, with her tendency to eavesdrop and make herself in all ways intrusive on her family and friends is a born again christian The novel is set in 1848 and the term born again was not in use until much later, but she fits the profile She was determined to save everyone and carried about her person tracts of her hero Miss Jane Ann Stamper Once she has invaded a house she would leave tracts scattered about in places where people would eventually find them, and hopefully receive the edification that Drusilla felt they needed She seemed like this on first appearances But like Drusilla from Buffy the Vampire Slayer she would pounce on people, not for blood, but for a chance to save their immortal souls As I have mentioned, all the characters are well developed and Drusilla is no exception She is a person, that after a previous encounter, you would go to great lengths to keep her from buttonholing you again This book delivers You will not be disappointed If I read it again I will put on a kettle of good English tea, light some candles, and tuck myself into an armchair, suspending myself as well as I can back into a Victorian age I had such a great time I will certainly be reading Wilkie Collins You are welcome to be as merry as you please over everything else I have written But when I write of Robinson Crusoe, by the Lord it s serious and I request you to take it accordingly If you wish to see of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit also have a Facebook blogger page at The problem with mysteries for me, anyway, is that I don t care who did it Which is a drawback I just think well, it s one of those characters the author has given a name to, it won t be the fourth man back on the upper deck of the omnibus mentioned briefly on page 211 It will be someone with a name And further, it will be someone who you don t think it will be, because that s the whole point You don t think it s going to be that person so it s a surprise So, if it turns out to be the not obvious person how could the little spinster with the gammy foot batter the ten foot Guardsman to death and scale the west wall on the fateful night Well, she was on Victorian crack is how I say wow, how obvious She was really not obviously the murderer, so she was obviously the murderer However, I really liked Wilkie s novelsThe Woman in White and No Name, so I read this In a modern detective tale, you have your detective, and there is a detective in this one, but he only occupies a short part of the story, he quickly retires to grow roses, literally, that s not a euphemism for some kind of rent boy scandal, so the rest of the story is made up by narratives from five or six main characters.Now comes the dance of the seven veils.Because if two narrators had been given their voice, the whole novel would have been over in 50 pages You get the longwinded thoughts of all the people who DON T know what actually happened By page 350, after being mumbled at, prevaricated over, and digressed to for what seemed days, NAY, weeks, by Wilkie Collins five narrators, all of whom suffer from amusing psychological tics and endearing human flaws, or was it the other way round, and all of whom could have summarised their tales onto two pages of foolscap, I was ready to shrink myself to the size of a capital R pronounced aargh and insert myself into this novel Fantastic Voyage style and grab a passing amateur sleuth and confess loudly I STOLE YOUR DAMNED MOONSTONE, ARREST ME, AND THERE S AN END OF IT Memo write future review of Victorian novel as if invested into it Fantastic Voyage style Should be hilarious Actually, there is a point to all this 430 pages of Moonstone The whole plot, and this, strangely enough, is not a spoiler, hangs on the attempt of one guy to give up smoking So The Moonstone is a very elaborate warning that going cold turkey is a bad idea, you must use the patches The Moonstone is often cited as the earliest medical warning story later examples are Dr Jeckyll and Mr Hyde, which concerns self medication and its dangers, and Henry James Daisy Miller, which explains to tourists that they must get all their vaccinations The genre is still thriving the recent movie Bad Lieutenant Port of New Orleans is all about inappropriate methods of combating severe back pain.In the end I thought this was the Monkees instead of The Beatles, Pleasant Valley Sunday instead of Tomorrow Never Knows. 4.5 stars, rounding up, for this 1868 Victorian era mystery, often considered the first English language detective novel Wilkie Collins spins a literary web that starts out slowly but then inexorably pulls you in I finished the last half of the book in one extended readathon He has a gift for writing as vastly different characters, who each take a turn telling or writing their part of the story, and a droll, sometimes very sarcastic sense of humor.In 1799 a British soldier steals a large yellow diamond from a Hindu statute in India, ruthlessly killing three Indian men protecting the statue, and earning himself a curse from one of them in the process He gets a bad reputation as a result and is shunned by his extended family in England So when he dies, he leaves the Moonstone to his niece Rachel whose mother refused to receive him as a guest in her home , knowing he s leaving her not only a 30,000 pound fortune in the jewel, but also a load of potential trouble there s not just the amorphous curse, but three Indian men who have been following the owners of the Moonstone for years and are determined to steal it back, one way or another.Rachel s relative Franklin Blake is entrusted with bringing her the diamond for her 18th birthday, and falls in love with her as he gets to know her over several days The Indians are lurking, looking for their chance to grab their gem Rachel wears the Moonstone at a dinner party the night of her birthday, puts the jewel in a drawer in her bedroom and the next morning it s gone The odd thing is, it looks like an inside job The bumbling local police are of little help, and even the renowned outside detective, the estimable Sergeant Cuff, is unable to bring the case to a satisfactory conclusion, though part of the problem is that several people aren t cooperating with him.Wilkie Collins doesn t try all that hard to hide the villain in the tale, but the how is fascinatingly revealed over the last half of the book I don t think Wilkie was particularly interested in giving readers all of the clues this isn t really a mystery that is supposed to be solved by readers before the big reveal, in my opinion the final reveal of exactly what went down that fateful night pretty much comes out of left field, though there are a few clues in the story He s interested in telling an exciting story, and he pulls just about everything into the mix a massive jewel, star crossed love, people hiding things for their own reasons, a servant with a highly suspicious past, dangerous quicksand, and a loyal servant with an amusing and rather touching devotion to Robinson Crusoe, which he treats as a sort of Bible Better him than Rachel s cousin Drusilla Clack, an annoying Christian evangelist given to preaching and leaving tracts with titles like Satan in the Hair Brush around people s homes This proto detective novel does get a little slow at times Victorian authors typically weren t in a hurry to tell their stories , but once the storyline really started moving along in the second half I thought it was a great read Plus points for handling the Indian subplot in a manner that s unusually sensitive for books written in the Victorian age. The following is a recently found letter written by the English author Charles Dickens to his friend Wilkie Collins concerning the latter s newly released 1868 novel The Moonstone Charles Dickens11 Gad s Hill PlaceHingham, KentEnglandNovember 13, 1868Dear Wilkie, I am now pressing my pen against this paper to congratulate you on the success of your excellent new novel, The Moonstone I have just completed reading it and I would like to present you with my opinion that this was, as they say, a true page turner in every sense of the word I am also taking the liberty to take this compliment a step further by stating that this is one of the finest mystery novels of all time I must confess that I have never actually read a book such as this that captures the sensation of a mysterious theft and a thorough investigation that follows it It was a fascinating read throughout as the solution to the mystery was also entirely above my suspicion I also thoroughly enjoyed the use of multi narration where the reader obtains various different viewpoints during the inquiry concerning the loss of the Indian diamond I believe that this novel, The Moonstone, has successfully maintained the same exceptional level of quality as your masterpiece, The Woman in White, and it ranks among the top tiers of the written pages from our fellow countrymen I have not the shadow of a doubt that this book will continue to enthrall readers for centuries to come The Moonstone is a best seller at the local bookseller here in Kent and my excitement for your continued success is immense Well done, my dear friend Wilkie We shall celebrate this achievement over a glass of Cognac Best wishes and I look forward to reading your future works.Your friend always,Charles Dickens . The Moonstone is known as the first detective novel , and it s a cracking one You can see things invented here that were directly borrowed by future writers Holmes overconfidence and his use of London urchins as agents Agatha Christie s exploration of narrative reliabilityas opposed to Poe s Dupin, which was the first detective storyI know, we re splitting hairs.And if the mystery s not enough for you, how about mysterious Oriental cultures Romance Quicksand Opium This is a ludicrously entertaining book, almost on the level of Count of Monte Cristo for sheer kicks Things I Was Super On The Watch For When I Was A Kid And It Turns Out They Are Not Actually Things Alligators Amnesia Chloroform soaked rags Razors in apples Steamrollers QuicksandIt shares with Collins other masterpiece, The Woman in White, a preoccupation with narrative from different sources, in different voices, with varying motives and degrees of reliability Like Woman in White, it s set up like a court case a series of witnesses come forward to tell their part of the story in or less chronological order, while commenting on and insulting each other s narratives Many characters also cite other texts Betteredge is obsessed with Robinson Crusoe Miss Clack carts around a variety of religious tracts, all of which are made up, which sucks because how badly do you want to read Satan in the Hairbrush and A Word With You On Your Cap Ribbons Pretty bad, man and finally, Ezra Jennings will cite De Quincey s landmark drug memoir Memoirs of an Opium Eater.Which, by the way unlike Woman in White 1860 , The Moonstone 1868 was written while Collins was deep in the throes of a laudanum addiction, and the whole thing can be seen as, or less, about opium.Also unlike Woman in White, which features one of my all time favorite female heroines, the diamond sharp Miss Halcombe, The Moonstone has an awkward relationship to women Many of its narrators are prone to statements like this Men being superior creatures are bound to improve women if they can When a woman wants me to do anything, I always insist on knowing why The oftener you make them rummage their own minds for a reason, the manageable you will find them in all the relations of life.The first couple times you see stuff like this you can figure Collins means for you to laugh at it but after like ten different people say things along similar lines, you do start to wonder a little.Woman in White just edges out Moonstone for me as my favorite Collins Its characters Miss Halcombe and the mighty Count Fosco are indelible than Moonstone s But The Moonstone includes a thinly disguised Richard Burton, as well as the terrifically bitchy Miss Clacklook, here s my secret I like Collins better than his buddy Dickens This book is a gang of fun. The Moonstone Is A Page Turner, Writes Carolyn Heilbrun It Catches One Up And Unfolds Its Amazing Story Through The Recountings Of Its Several Narrators, All Of Them Enticing And Singular Wilkie Collins S Spellbinding Tale Of Romance, Theft, And Murder Inspired A Hugely Popular Genre The Detective Mystery Hinging On The Theft Of An Enormous Diamond Originally Stolen From An Indian Shrine, This Riveting Novel Features The Innovative Sergeant Cuff, The Hilarious House Steward Gabriel Betteridge, A Lovesick Housemaid, And A Mysterious Band Of Indian JugglersThis Modern Library Paperback Classic Is Set From The Definitive Edition Though Wilkie Collins was long time friends with Charles Dickens, they had drastically different writing styles, and suffered some rough patches in their relationship In a letter to someone, Dickens talks about his thoughts on The Moonstone The construction is wearisome beyond endurance, and there is a vein of obstinate conceit in it that makes enemies of readers What the heck Who s this Dickens guy, anyway What the heck does he know about writing Sheesh I don t know what book the vaunted Mr Charles Dickens read, but the book I read was absolutely wonderful It was hilarious, entertaining, smart, and everything else that makes a good novel Beyond that, it was especially surprising Being one of the first detective novels, I expected it to be rather dry Maybe a little dull, or outdated feeling Perhaps even a bit shallow and boring I m pleased to say, that it was none of these things For a book written in the mid 1800 s this novel has a remarkably modern feel Though the main plot is a detective style mystery, there is a wonderful underlying social commentary aspect, all revealed through the lenses of the unique cast of characters The story is brilliantly told by using various written narratives of different people, all which not only tease us with knowledge of the mystery at just the right pace, but also provide wildly entertaining character studies of the people writing them From my favorite character the chauvinistic old butler, who wants nothing than to serve his household faithfully while leaning upon the crutch of Robinson Crusoe and his tobacco pipe, to the absolutely, but painfully, hilarious distant cousin who is on a mission to convert everyone to her particular brand of christian values Each character s narrative is written in their unique voice, and it makes you love them all even when you re hating them.I think Collins himself puts it perfectly, when he said that, unlike examining the influence of circumstances upon character as many other novels , this book examines the influence of character upon circumstance This isn t some novel where you place an average person in an extraordinary situation, and watch what becomes of them This is a novel where the extraordinary characters are the movers and shakers of the plot Yet, even as wonderfully unique as these characters are, they are all at the same time, so wonderfully human With the narrative style Collins chose, we are allowed insight into the characters thought processes, and feelings we are able to see than what actually happens In many other novels, this approach might generate superfluous noise, but in The Moonstone it keeps the book churning at a page burning pace, and allows us to appreciate the smaller aspects of the novel, even when the larger parts might normally be prepared to overshadow them This book almost feels like one of those guilty pleasure books people always try to judge others for reading, but you can hold your head high on this one It s fun, fast paced, and riveting, but nobody can accuse it of being shallow Each character brings not only a unique perspective on the main plot mystery of the novel, but also a unique perspective on the world around them Let s explore what I mean with a couple of my favorite gentlefolk, shall we The old butler People in high life have all the luxuries to themselves among others, the luxury of indulging their feelings People in low life have no such privilege Necessity, which spares our betters, has no pity on us We learn to put our feelings back into ourselves, and to jog on with our duties as patiently as may be I don t complain of this I only notice itThere s a bottom of good sense, Mr Franklin, in our conduct to our mothers, when they first start us on the journey of life We are all of us or less unwilling to be brought into this world And we are all of us right. The self righteous cousin, whose only want is to share her beloved tracts I paid the cabman exactly his fare He received it with an oath upon which I instantly gave him a tract If I had presented a pistol at his head, this abandoned wretch could hardly have exhibited greater consternation He jumped up on his box, and, with profane exclamations of dismay, drove off furiously Quite useless, I am happy to say I sowed the good seed, in spite of him, by throwing a second tract in at the window of the cab. When I folded up my things that night when I reflected on the true riches which I had scattered with such a lavish hand, from top to bottom of the house of my wealthy aunt I declare I felt as free from all anxiety as if I had been a child again I was so lighthearted that I sang a verse of the Evening Hymm I was so lighthearted that I fell asleep before I could sing another Quite like a child again Quite like a child again So I passed the blissful night On rising the next morning, how young I felt I might add, how young I looked, if I were capable of dwelling on the concerns of my own perishable body But I am not capable and I add nothing. Even though I could go on and on with wonderfully entertaining passages, I realize I ve already over done it on the quotations, so this humble reviewer must desist before he loses himself Basically, read this book If you like detective novels, or if you like Victorian novels, or if you like novels in general, read this It s quite fun The true mark of a great mystery novel is that even if you know or solved the mystery, the book still manages to keep your attention and make you want to see the conclusion unfold for yourself I can t imagine re reading most mystery novels I can think of, but I can t imagine not re reading The Moonstone again in the future It s simply too much fun A small, religious pamphlet. I was torn between giving two stars and three stars to Wilkie Collins s The Moonstone, a book T S Eliot called the first, the longest, and the best of modern English detective novels Longest is perhaps the operative word here, reminding one of Samuel Johnson s comment speaking, in his case, of Milton s Paradise Lost that none ever wished it longer The Moonstone s length, in the end, is its chief and perhaps only major failing Large chunks of the novel seem to drag on and on with few advancements being made to the plot in the process The latter parts of the section narrated by Gabriel Betteredge, chief servant to the Verinder household, and almost all of Drusilla Clack s section really could have used some judicious editing.I suspect, though, that long after I forget what a slog much of The Moonstone was to get through, I ll remember its many charms Betteredge is a particularly fun narrator, given his obsession with Daniel Defoe s Robinson Crusoe a book he treats as a cross between the Holy Bible and Nostradamus s Prophecies and his jaundiced eye toward male female relations Collins also must have had a ball making Drusilla Clack one of the most judgmental, grating Christian evangelists in English literature Particularly priceless are the passages in which she wanders around the Verinder household and strategically places religious tracts in spots where family members, she hopes, would just happen upon them, instantly putting her relatives on the path to salvation.Betteredge and Clack are so compelling that almost every other character in The Moonstone, with the possible exception of opium addict Ezra Jennings, pales in comparison Rachel Verinder despite being at the book s center as the recipient of the Indian diamond known as the Moonstone, the theft of which the plot revolves around isn t as fully drawn as the other characters, perhaps because she never takes over narration of the story This, in a way, actually demonstrates one of Collins s chief skills as a writer as each narrator takes his or her turn telling the story, that section of the book really becomes about him or her than about the plot.And that, ultimately, is what makes The Moonstone an interesting book Despite being such an early and influential mystery novel it predated Arthur Conan Doyle s introduction of Sherlock Holmes by almost two decades it s really about the characters themselves, their view of the world, and the decisions they make than it is about solving the mystery of the diamond s disappearance It s a shame that of today s mystery novelists haven t learned that lesson from The Moonstone In retrospect, I realize I m perhaps making The Moonstone sound like of a four star book, but trust me the long, drawn out sections of the book really are incredibly long and drawn out I cannot overstate just how much this book tests the reader s patience, and for scores of pages at a time.